The First Question Is the Before Photo
When a client calls claiming a technician cracked the deck, the conversation depends entirely on what the documentation shows. A before photo that clearly shows the crack before any work began resolves the dispute with evidence rather than argument. A job where no before photos were taken puts the technician in a much harder position.
This is why LBA teaches pre-evaluation photography as non-negotiable. Not because every customer will make a claim. Because the one who does will require evidence.
Stay calm and do not argue
A defensive or emotional response from the technician or business owner makes the situation worse. Listen to what the customer is saying before responding. Their perception of the situation matters even if the facts do not support their claim.
Review the before photos immediately
Before responding with any position, pull up the evaluation photos. Look for the crack in question in the pre-evaluation photos taken at arrival. If it is there, you have your answer. If it is not there, you need to review what actually happened during the evaluation before making any claim about what caused it.
Show the documentation factually
"I want to look at this with you. We photograph all site conditions before we begin the evaluation. Here is a photo taken at arrival - this shows the deck as it was when we arrived. I can see [crack / no crack] in this photo." Present the evidence without lecturing or accusing.
Explain what the evaluation involved
Standard pool leak detection involves visual assessment, underwater evaluation, dye testing, and pressure testing of plumbing lines. It does not involve striking the deck, cutting concrete, applying force to coping, or doing anything that would cause a new crack in sound deck material. Walk the customer through what the evaluation actually consisted of if they are unclear.
If something genuinely may have happened, be honest
If the evaluation involved something unusual - acoustic equipment placed on a visibly compromised section of deck, pressure testing equipment that may have affected a weak area - review it honestly. If there is any reasonable possibility the technician contributed to a new crack, that requires involvement of your insurance, not a defensive denial.
The pre-evaluation photo is the best protection that exists for this situation. A photo taken on arrival showing the deck condition before any work began removes the guesswork and resolves most claims quickly. Technicians who photograph deck cracks, loose coping, settled pavers, and damaged surfaces before starting the job have documentation to stand on. Technicians who do not photograph arrival conditions have a much harder conversation when a dispute arises.
Document Every Job Like It Might Be Disputed
LBA teaches pre-evaluation photography and documentation as standard practice - because the job you do not document is the job you cannot defend.
View LBA Courses